RSS FeedFacebookSearch
Gary Younge
Europe’s Democracy Deficit

Imagine NAFTA as a tiny

—the precursor to a larger, supranational feast. Imagine it came with structural funds to promote economic development in struggling areas—from Michigan to Monterrey to Manitoba—and a social chapter to shore up workers’ rights, and then the borders were thrown open so that labor could move freely along with capital. Imagine it then served up a North American Congress elected every five years from across the continent and added a North American Court of Human Rights. And then for the main course, it took the dollar (Canadian and US) and the peso off the menu and replaced them with a new currency (let’s call it the americano), which would be administered by the North American Central Bank.

This extensive buffet might not be to everyone’s liking. Indeed, some may gag from the get-go while others gorge themselves. Some utopians might champion it as the harbinger of a more social democratic world; others might argue it would further weaken unions and labor. But most would agree that such a bold project would demand democratic consent to be built and democratic control once it existed. The absence of those two basic factors would not only deprive the entire scheme of legitimacy but disable it from functioning properly.

Welcome to the eurozone and the European Union, struggling to maintain its credibility in the face of market speculation, popular protests and government ambivalence. The euro has lost about 14 percent of its value against the dollar this year alone. The weakest members of the eurozone—Greece, Portugal, Ireland and Spain—are threatened with ejection. Italy may soon find itself among them. Meanwhile, the strongest, France and Germany, are questioning the currency’s survival.

The curious thing about this crisis is that on paper Europe’s economies are not in terrible shape compared with the rest of the Western world. EU unemployment is marginally lower than in the United States (9.7 percent as opposed to 9.9 percent) as is the inflation rate (1.8 percent versus 2.2 percent). True, growth and productivity are lower too, so there’s little reason for anyone to dance a jig down the Champs-Élysées. But fiscally it is far from an unmitigated disaster. According to the OECD, the US deficit, as a percentage of GDP, is higher than that in Greece, Spain, Portugal and Italy—all in the cross hairs of the markets—and its public debt as a percentage of GDP is higher than that in Portugal, Ireland and Spain.

But Europe’s primary problem—the reason it has been lurching from crisis to crisis as the markets tank, the Greeks and Spaniards protest, and the Germans and French bicker—is not its fiscal deficit but its democratic deficit.

For the only thing more breathtaking than the scale and pace at which the EU has developed, from a small, tariff-free trading area to a twenty-seven-nation union with a common currency, court of human rights and central bank, is the lack of democracy that has gone with it. Go back to that imaginary North American superstate and imagine this—absolutely no direct democratic control over anything as an explicit feature of the system.

© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc
Stranger in a Strange Land – Encounters in the Disunited States
book review
'It often takes an outsider to look inside. This is especially true of the United States.'
 follow on twitter
Livestream available
RT @TalawaTheatreCo: Hey! We're looking for new young trustees aged between 18 and 25. Join us, and help shape the future of Talawa. All d…
RT @RSLiterature: To kick-off our #LiteratureMatters #RSL200 Autumn/Winter events, join @DavidHarewood & @GaryYounge live @britishlibrary t…
RT @gavinesler: The prime minister of the United Kingdom in his own words ….
RT @EuceEsc: We are so excited to announce that during Pitt's #InternationalWeek2021, Gary Younge will be (virtually) delivering the 2021-2…
There are so many wonderful things about this photograph.
@DavidHarewood @britishlibrary Can I have your pies?
RT @DavidHarewood: @DavidHarewood /@garyyounge It’s ON! See the heavyweight battle everyone’s talking about! @britishlibrary for ONE night…
@carysafoko @DavidHarewood @britishlibrary Spite. It’s my superpower
Very much looking forward to being in conversation with @DavidHarewood at the @britishlibrary in London on October…
© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc