RSS FeedFacebookSearch
Gary Younge
Indiscreet Conversations

The iPhone has a new application–a GPS navigational system called Loopt. If you’re out and about and you want to know if your friends are in the neighborhood, your phone can tell them where you are and theirs tells you where they are. You’re in the loop. With technology like this, it’s a wonder anyone has affairs anymore. Total information: constant contact, anytime, all the time. There’s almost literally nowhere left to hide.

What is true in our personal lives is increasingly true in our political culture. Jesse Jackson was caught whispering sour nothings about Barack Obama to a fellow guest on Fox News. "Barack’s been talking down to black people," Jackson said. "I wanna cut his nuts off."

He thought the mic was off. He should have known better. In 1984 in a conversation with

reporter Milton Coleman, Jackson referred to Jews as "Hymies" and New York as "Hymietown." "Let’s talk black talk," he told Coleman, assuming that meant it would be off the record. When Coleman decided to publish it, Jackson at first denied it, then finally admitted it and apologized. This time there was no denial–there couldn’t have been. With blogs, webcams, Facebook and YouTube, there is always a mic somewhere and it is always on.

There is, in short, no such thing as a discreet conversation anymore. The personal, the private, the privileged and the confidential no longer really exist. The stories you may choose not to share are not yours to keep; the conversations you hope will go no further can just keep traveling. A remark may be off the cuff or off the top of your head–but nowadays you must always assume it’s on the record.

The fact that this discourages public figures from speaking their mind is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it deters open and honest intellectual engagement and development. People generally arrive at positions through discussion and debate and trial and error. But the days when they could think out loud are fast disappearing. A culture desperately in need of ideas is giving its political class no place to think. If you feel the mic is always on, you will always perform. Politicians have to forgo the right to be angry, exasperated, depressed or funny–or at least they reveal those emotions at great risk to their credibility. Their human qualities–the very thing we need more of–become a liability.

On the other hand, it can pry candor from the lips of the caged and the canny. It exposed Trent Lott’s nostalgia for segregation and Republican George Allen’s "macaca" moment that effectively derailed his Senate race in Virginia.

In Jackson’s case, it gave furtive voice to his ambivalence toward Obama. Not, as some claim, because Obama has usurped his mantle as leader of Black America but because Jackson is a radical and Obama is not. They emerge from the same city but different traditions and moments, so there is no reason that they should necessarily agree or even get along. Having endorsed Obama early on, Jackson rarely spoke out for him. This seemed to work well for both of them. So it’s not as though Jackson was caught saying something he didn’t really believe or that represents a distortion of his position. Quite the opposite. He was caught saying something he did feel but had no intention of sharing. Put bluntly, his problem was that he got caught.

© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc
Stranger in a Strange Land – Encounters in the Disunited States
book review
'It often takes an outsider to look inside. This is especially true of the United States.'
 follow on twitter
RT @JonWiener1: "Almost no other protest group could've done what they did. They would've been gunned down and that would've been it." Gary…
RT @meghanetinsley: This plan is a terrible way to remember Britain’s wars, and a great way to erase history. Thread.…
RT @MsJeanRhys: Don't stop.
RT @GeorgeMonbiot: £500 for everyone with Covid, as delivered by Chartwells.
People celebrating a return to normal should understand that ‘normal’ is what got us here.
RT @GeorgeMonbiot: I suspect we may be stuck in a cycle of euphoria and sentimentality, followed by disappointment, alienation and reaction…
This is very smart and very interesting, not least because it manages to be deeply critical but generous in spirit.
RT @JonWiener1: The insurrectionists of January 6 failed to stop Congress from certifying Biden as the winner of the election—so what WAS t…
RT @TrueFactsStated: The internet is finding its joy again. Sorry, @SenSanders
RT @owen_g: The Guardian view on Joe Biden's inauguration: democracy prevails – for now
© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc