RSS FeedFacebookSearch
Gary Younge
Obama and the Power of Symbols

After France won the 1998 World Cup, the French commentariat went into overdrive. Unlike the country’s political class, the team contained a broad racial and ethnic cross section of French society. The image of the soccer team’s star player, Zinédine Zidane, who is of Algerian descent, was projected on the Arc de Triomphe. "What better example of our unity and our diversity than this magnificent team?" asked Socialist Prime Minister Lionel Jospin. Before the first whistle had been blown for the next World Cup, in 2002, the French electorate were clearly having second thoughts about unity and diversity. In presidential elections that year Jospin was beaten into third place by French far-right leader Jean-Marie Le Pen, who won 17 percent of the vote.

There are symbols, and there is substance–the way things look, and the way things are. But in between there is the way things might be: a sense of possibility that image might precede content or even provide space for it to emerge. A leap of faith. Some wishful thinking. Such is the tension in the American left’s response to Obama’s candidacy. There are some–let’s call them dreamers–who believe his nomination marks a paradigm shift in progressive politics in this country. And there are others–let’s call them materialists–who dismiss the excitement surrounding his nomination as little more than an emotional distraction from what really matters: war, foreclosures, civil liberties, the Middle East, global warming.

On these issues, point out the materialists, Obama is little more than a mainstream Democrat offering sops that are better than the Republicans’ but inadequate to the needs of working-class Americans and the world at large. If you look at what he does rather than how he looks, they continue, then there is no more reason to be excited about him than about John Kerry.

To evoke the historic significance of an Obama victory is to provoke the materialists’ scorn. They ask for one scrap of evidence that the election of a black President will improve the lives of black people in this country. The dreamer mutters something vague about role models for young black men.

The materialists have a point. In a country whose self-image is underpinned by notions of social fluidity and eternal progress, it is possible to overemphasize the ramifications of Obama’s nomination. Those who claim that having a black President will present a positive image of America to the rest of the world must remember that for the past eight years that face has been Colin Powell and Condoleezza Rice–and that has not worked out so well for the rest of the world. Moreover, electoral progress does not necessarily translate into social progress. The late Benazir Bhutto of Pakistan was the first elected woman leader of a Muslim state. But her prime ministership did very little for the women of Pakistan.

Indeed, Obama’s candidacy is not consistent with the social rise of African-Americans but aberrant from it. According to a November report by the Pew Research Center, black Americans are more dissatisfied with their progress than at any time in the past twenty-five years. Another Pew survey released at the same time shows that almost half (45 percent) of African-Americans born to middle-income parents in the post-civil rights era have descended into poverty or near poverty as adults.

© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc
No Place Like Home – A Black Briton’s Journey through the American South
book review
'The idea of retracing the route is a great one, urgent and necessary.'
 follow on twitter
RT @wowfest: 📢📢📢 TIME TO ANNOUNCE OUR BLACK HISTORY MONTH FESTIVAL 1st October- 31st October Featuring @garyyounge @galdemzine @CallMrRobe
RT @theracebeat: We're looking forward to being in Glasgow next week with @garyyounge @arusaqureshi @shola_mcafro @Chess_Ess and many more…
RT @typemediacenter: #ICYMI, read @garyyounge’s recent five-part @guardian series on the challenges, tensions, and vast untapped potential…
RT @MSNBC: 2017 marked the first time firearms killed more people than motor vehicle accidents, according to a new report. https://t.co/zvf…
"Aimee was generous, always guiding outreach workers to homeless people she considered vulnerable. She was less goo… https://t.co/6M64Or8KoG
RT @LSHGofficial: The Staying Power of Peter Fryer - Discussion with contributions from @DavidOlusoga @garyyounge, and Terry Brotherstone.…
RT @DrFrancesRyan: “Austerity was absolutely a choice. You chose to hurt communities.” @Miatsf absolutely destroys Kate Andrews and a Tory…
RT @NesrineMalik: ‘It is not talent but access to the right people, the adventurism of those with nothing to lose, the financial comfort th…
RT @NLawrenceOBE: We always mark the birthday of our son Stephen. We will never forget him. I also remember others suffering the ongoing gr…
RT @hoperoadpublish: We've got that #FridayFeeling, as the weekend is prime book reading time! Looking for a great diverse read? #TheNowh
© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc