RSS FeedFacebookSearch
Gary Younge
Wal-Mart drops racy lads' mags

America's biggest retailer, Wal-Mart, has dropped three bestselling lad magazines, Maxim, FHM and Stuff, because the words are too racy and the pictures too bawdy.

The company, which has been criticised by Christian groups in the past for some of the magazines it stocks, said it had decided to ban these three "after listening to our customers and associates."

"They write to us or contact us and tell us what they think and we listen," a spokeswoman said yesterday. "A number of them said they were uncomfortable with these products."

She refused to say what, in particular, makes them uncomfortable or how many had complained.

The company, which has special versions of albums made and covers redrawn to fit its moral code, dominates the market.

Dennis Publishing USA, which owns Maxim and Stuff, shrugged off the decision, saying Wal-Mart sold less than 3% of total news-stand sales.

"Like a lot of categories of magazines, we have our ups and downs with Wal-Mart, depending on what is in the issue," its president, Stephen Colvin, told the New York Times.

Wal-Mart's British subsidiary Asda will not follow suit. A spokesman said the three titles were among its biggest selling magazines.

"We will continue to sell them. They are our top selling men's magazines.

"Wal-Mart based their decision on customer feedback but, as far as we are concerned, our customers are happy with the content.

"Clearly we do not merchandise them next to children's magazines and they are sold in plastic wrappers. But they are very popular with our customers".

Last year Wal-Mart refused to stock an issue of Sports Illustrated's swimsuit special because it took exception to one photograph.

"Maybe they think Tyra Banks should have been wearing pink instead of black," Mr Colvin said.

"I don't think that these decisions are often rational ... For any men's magazine to put a woman on the cover seems a bit troubling to them."

One mutual funds management company, which will not invest in businesses "involved in practices contrary to Judeo-Christian principles", has been pressing Wal-Mart to remove women's magazines such as Cosmopolitan and Glamour from the checkout line.

Arthur Ally, president of Timothy Plan, whose goal is "to recapture traditional values", said magazines like Maxim and FHM were even worse.

"It is soft-core pornography," he said. "It's very addictive and leads to harder stuff."

Mr Colvin's apparent indifference to the ban masks the fact that Wal-Mart's moral decisions matter, because it is such a giant among American retailers.

With 1.3 million workers, it is the world's biggest private employer, and the top seller in the US of DVDs, groceries, jewellery and photo processing.

With a computer network which rivals the Pentagon's, and contributing as much as 25% of US productivity gains in 1995-99, it wields an influence in the American economy not seen since Standard Oil in the 19th century.

Its arrival in any small town usually signals the end of all smaller outlets.

This, a spokeswoman for the most popular civil liberties advocates, the American Civil Liberties Union, said, imposed particular responsibilities on the company.

"It has literally the same practical effect in many communities as outright government censorship," Nadine Strossen, the ACLU president, said.

© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc
Stranger in a Strange Land – Encounters in the Disunited States
book review
'It often takes an outsider to look inside. This is especially true of the United States.'
 follow on twitter
@Claire_Trini So basically after a week of looking for them they’ve come to find me!
"Home is wherever [Younge] finds kindred spirits; he’s discovered members of his “tribe” everywhere." An very gener… https://t.co/6xkOv8kLaz
RT @NesrineMalik: Sure, things are bad for Muslims, but have you considered the implications of defining Islamophobia on those writing abou…
RT @AnnaGordonPics: @garyyounge We are a group of female press photographers who are unhappy with a recent exhibition put on by the Britis…
RT @mtholyoke: “You only get one life. However short it is, it is enough to make a difference and make sure you leave the planet in a bette…
RT @heyjudeTT: A few words @Newsday_TT about @garyyounge & his last book from when he was here for @bocaslitfest. Excellent book, lovely b…
RT @AbiWilks: @garyyounge He’s asking you to think through the consistency of your political moral, & the issues you do/don’t care about, i…
"The most authentic slogan [Boris Johnson] could run under would be: “Not a serious person for not a serious countr… https://t.co/vSX6R1qcMH
Change UK was always doomed to failure, and Joan Ryan just showed why | Owen Jones https://t.co/FMatzkk4gF
© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc