RSS FeedFacebookSearch
Gary Younge
Why Michelin stars may not shine in New York

"I think it's big risk for Michelin," said Ruth Reichl, editor of Gourmet magazine and former restaurant critic for the New York Times. "If they chose restaurants here New Yorkers don't like then New Yorkers will say: 'The French can say what they like but we know what we like. Who cares what they think?' But at the same time they will risk their reputation for getting it right in Europe too."

"Michelin is not a household name in America," said John Schaefer, executive chef at the Gramercy Tavern.

"Your foodies are aware of it but for most people it will be a whole new deal. It's got to be a positive thing."

The book, on sale in November, will rate 500 restaurants in New York's five boroughs, according to Michelin's star rating. One star means worth "a visit"; two mean worthy of "a detour", and three are reserved for those which merit a "special trip".

In a country where congressmen recently sought to turn French fries into Freedom fries in protest at French opposition to the Iraq war, Michelin faces cultural barriers beyond food.

"The fact that they are French will be a subject of dismissal and fun for the kind of people who read the New York Post," says Colman Andrews, editor-in-chief of Saveur, a food and drink magazine, based in New York, referring to Rupert Murdoch's tabloid. "But it will be greatly appreciated by those who read the New York Times."

Whether the Michelin team is aware or indeed concerned by the possibility that they may spark a transatlantic, gastronomic controversy is unclear. "A New York guide is part of an old dream of mine," Edouard Michelin, the chairman of the tyre company responsible for the guide, told the New York Times. "It goes back 20 years. At first there was France, then Europe, but now there's the world, and New York is the gateway. New York makes you discover other cuisines."

Not all of the inspectors, who dine undeclared only to be followed up by another inspector who will reveal his or her identity and ask to see the kitchen, are French.

But Ms Reichl points out that they will have to understand that the economic model for American restaurants is not the same as Europe's.

"If they are very put off by the fact that they have to wait for a table that will be a problem," she said. "There is a frenetic quality to New York restaurants that the French just don't have. But with that there is a certain amount of energy."

There is also a wide variety of ethnic foods with which Michelin's European palate may be ill-acquainted.

"One problem with Michelin has been that when they go outside of French they tend to reward restaurants with a French style rather than on their own terms," says Mr Andrews. "One of the tests of their sophistication will be to see whether they are able to judge a good steak house."

The ratings system may also throw New Yorkers. "Michelin will have to do a bit of explaining with only three stars at the top," said Eric Ripert, the chef and a partner in Le Bernardin, a restaurant that had two Michelin stars in Paris when it moved to New York. "Most of the newspaper reviewers here go up to four stars."

© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc
Stranger in a Strange Land – Encounters in the Disunited States
book review
'It often takes an outsider to look inside. This is especially true of the United States.'
 follow on twitter
RT @NEF: Don't miss this fantastic discussion with @garyyounge about the rise in knife crime: policing, austerity, education, and racism al…
RT @MichaelRosenYes: Computer fail at Euston station. Can’t collect prepaid tickets. Corbyn again.
RT @JackieKayPoet: My son @mattkaywolf when he was three (he is thirty now!) used to say to me, mummy why are you always going to poetry? H…
RT @MarinaHyde: Don Trump Jr is still probably not the stupidest person ever to have been given a column at the Telegraph because of their…
RT @PColemanchester: Homophobic parents are right to be worried about their children turning gay after lessons about LGBT awareness. I live…
RT @chakrabortty: “The moment a national newspaper publishes a piece of extremist propaganda in full then it has a potential reach of tens…
RT @Lanre_Bakare: Applying for the Scott Trust Bursary was the smartest thing I've ever done. God knows we need more working class and poc…
RT @marcusryder: On the same day England's Danny Rose backs Raheem Sterling in criticising UK media's portrayal of black players @bcomstwee
RT @HeaneyDaily: There were dragonflies, spotted butterflies, But best of all was the warm thick slobber Of frogspawn that grew like clotte…
© Gary Younge. All Rights reserved, site built with tlc